 |
Fresh, updated classic American cooking,
this James Beard award winner serves fluffy omelets,
pancakes from scratch, salads, sandwiches, meatloaf
and grilled meats and fish.
Beer and well priced wines.
Indoor and outdoor dining at this historic 1800's clapboard
landmark building in the heart of Old Town.
Fruity Beginning
Fresh Orange
Juice ... 4.00
Four Flowers Juice ... especially delicious ... 4.50
... orange and pomegranate juices blended with fresh pineapple and banana
Porridge
7.25
Slow cooked,
real rolled oats, served with your choice of the following:
non
fat milk, whole milk, or even better… fresh
cream,
organic honey, raisins, sliced bananas,
strawberries, wheatberries,
butter, brown sugar
Cereal
6.75
Sara’s
fresh toasted granola topped with bananas and raisins,
served with honey and your choice of milk or yogurt
Extraordinary Eggs And Omelets
…all
of our egg dishes are served with your choice of sourdough
toast,
8-grain toast, our classic pumpkin muffin or a
fresh corn muffin,
and Sarabeth’s
Marmalade
Add some of our 3 pepper potatoes
to any egg plate … 1.50
Sunnyside
up, Coddled, or Scrambled Eggs … 7.50
Green
And White …9.75
… scrambled
eggs with scallions and cream cheese
Goldie
Lox …10.25
… our
signature; silky smoked salmon scrambled with
eggs
and cream cheese
The
Red Omelet … 9.50
… filled
with cheddar cheese and a chunky sauce of
tomatoes
and red peppers, then topped with a dollop
of sour
cream with chives
Farmers
Omelet … 10.25
… sautéed
leeks, ham and chunks of potato with
gruyere
cheese
Fresh
Vegetable and Ricotta Omelet … 9.75
… tomatoes, sautéed
onions, broccoli and ricotta
Spinach
And Goat Cheese Omelet … 9.95
… nothing
more need be said, silky perfection
Key West Pink Shrimp and Bacon Omelet … 11.75
… with scallions and herbs and smoked mozzarella
|

Sweet Breakfasts
… all of our sweet breakfasts are served with real
Canadian Maple Syrup and sweet butter
Buttermilk
Pancakes … 9.75
… a
simply perfect classic with fresh strawberries
Lemon Ricotta Pancakes … 10.25
… the
traditional favorite with strawberries and
wheatberries
Pumpkin Waffle … 9.75
… topped
with sour cream, raisins,
pumpkin
seeds and honey
Fat And Fluffy French Toast … 9.50
… been
serving this dish for 20 years, sliced
strawberry
is all we add
Almond Crusted Cinnamon French Toast … 10.25
… with
a spoonful of apple butter and bananas
Side Orders,
For the Table …
or
Yourself
Fresh
Herb & Turkey Sausage … 4.00
3
Pepper Potatoes … 3.00
Side Order
Of Bacon … 4.00
Sourdough or 8-grain
toast, Pumpkin Muffin or Corn Muffin with marmalade … 2.50
|
|

|

Breakfast … all
Afternoon
… all
of our egg dishes are served
with your
choice of Cole's Peace sourdough
toast, 8-grain toast,
our classic
pumpkin muffin or a
fresh corn
muffin, and Sarabeth’s
Marmalade
… Add
our 3 pepper potatoes to
any egg plate … 1.50
… sweet
breakfasts are served with
real maple
syrup and sweet
butter
Goldie
Lox … 10.25
… our
signature; silky smoked
salmon
scrambled with eggs
and
cream cheese
Spinach and Goat Cheese
Omelet … 9.95
… nothing
more need be said,
silky
perfection
Lemon Ricotta Pancakes … 10.25
… the
traditional favorite with
strawberries
& wheatberries
Buttermilk Pancakes … 9.75
… a simply perfect classic with
sliced
strawberries
|
Side
Dishes … 4.00
each
Crispy French
Fries
Jicama Cole Slaw
Marinated Tomatoes
3-Pepper Home Fries (3.00)
Sliced Avocado
|
|
Sara’s
Velvety Cream Of Tomato Soup …8.25
… a
cherished recipe; chunks of tomato, cream, fresh
herbs, and other delicious things
Griddled
Smoked Mozzarella Sandwich …14.25
… with
sliced avocado and fresh tomato on 8-grain
bread with a side of
mango, pineapple and jicama
slaw
Our Classic Open Faced Tuna
Salad Sandwich … 14.00
… with
chopped tomatoes marinated in aged balsamic,
extra
virgin olive oil, and basil, served with garlic
rubbed
sliced grilled sourdough
Fresh
Roasted Turkey Club Sandwich … 14.25
… real
roast turkey, with warm smoky bacon, sliced
tomatoes,
romaine and smoked mozzarella on
8-grain toast
with maple mustard mayonnaise and
served
with our house cut french fries
Key West “Pinks” Shrimp
Salad … 14.75
… chilled
poached shrimp dressed in a light lemon
mayonnaise with celery hearts, and fresh chives,
topped with sliced avocado and served with
a simple salad
One
Great Simple Burger … 13.95
… fresh ground beef, charbroiled
and served with
arugula and sliced tomato and
our house cut french
fries
… with cheddar or gruyere cheese…add
1.00
Our Traditional Caesar
Salad … 12.00
… cold and crunchy hearts of romaine
lightly dressed
with a simple combination of
fresh egg, anchovy,
lemon, garlic and parmesan, served
with crispy
sourdough croutons and shaved
aged parmesan
(may be ordered with cubed,
roasted chicken
… add 4.00)
Poached
Salmon “Cobb” Salad … 14.95
… chilled, fresh
poached salmon, sweet corn,
cucumbers, wheatberries, tomato
relish and romaine
lettuce with basil buttermilk
dressing. Roasted
chicken may be substituted for
salmon.
Grilled Fresh Dolphin or Sautéed Lump Crabmeat and Key West Pink Shrimp Cake … 14.95
… served with a salad of baby lettuce,
avocado, snap
peas, cherry tomatoes
and sliced new potatoes,
dressed with a citrus
soy vinaigrette
Chicken Salad … 14.95
… roasted
chicken breast , tossed with fresh mango,
roasted
poblanos, diced cucumber and pumpkin
seeds
with a creamy herb dressing, some baby
greens
and toast
Green Chile Pepper Macaroni and Cheese … 14.95
…green chili pepper aged cheddar, mozarella
and parmesean cheeses.
|
|
|
Fruity Beginning
Fresh Orange Juice
... 4.00
Four Flowers Juice ... especially delicious ... 4.50
... orange and pomegranate juices blended with fresh pineapple and
banana
Porridge
7.25
Slow cooked,
real rolled oats, served with your choice of the following:
non fat milk, whole milk, or even better… fresh cream,
organic honey, raisins, sliced bananas, strawberries, wheatberries,
butter, brown sugar
Cereal
6.75
Sara’s fresh toasted granola topped with bananas and raisins,
served with honey and your choice of milk or yogurt
Extraordinary Eggs And Omelets
…all of our egg
dishes are served with your choice of sourdough toast,
8-grain toast, our classic pumpkin muffin or a fresh corn muffin,
and Sarabeth’s Marmalade
Add some of our 3 pepper potatoes to any egg plate … 1.50
Sunnyside up,
Coddled, or Scrambled Eggs …
Green And White …9.75
… scrambled eggs with scallions and
cream cheese
Goldie Lox … 10.25
… our signature; silky smoked salmon
scrambled with
eggs and cream cheese
The Red Omelet … 9.50
… filled with cheddar cheese and a
chunky sauce of
tomatoes and red peppers,
then topped with a dollop
of sour cream with chives
Farmers Omelet … 10.25
… sautéed leeks, ham and chunks
of potato with
gruyere cheese
Fresh Vegetable and Ricotta Omelet … 9.75
… tomatoes, sautéed onions,
broccoli and ricotta
Spinach And Goat Cheese Omelet … 9.95
… nothing more need be said, silky
perfection
Key West Pink Shrimp and Bacon Omelet … 11.75
… with scallions, and herbs,
and smoked mozzarella
|

Sweet Breakfasts
9.50
… all of our sweet breakfasts are served with real
Canadian Maple Syrup and sweet butter
Buttermilk Pancakes … 9.75
… a simply
perfect classic with fresh strawberries
Lemon Ricotta Pancakes … 10.25
… the
traditional favorite with strawberries and
wheatberries
Pumpkin Waffle … 9.75
… topped
with sour cream, raisins, pumpkin seeds
and
honey
Fat And Fluffy French Toast … 9.50
… been
serving this dish for 20 years, sliced
strawberry is all we add
Almond Crusted Cinnamon French
Toast … 10.25
… with
a spoonful of apple butter and bananas
Side Orders,
For the Table …
or Yourself
Fresh Chicken Apple Sausage … 4.00
3 Pepper Potatoes … 3.00
Side Order Of Bacon … 4.00
Sourdough or 8-grain toast, Pumpkin Muffin or Corn Muffin with marmalade … 2.50
|
|
Served 11 a.m. - 3 p.m.
Sara’s
Velvety Cream Of Tomato Soup … 8.25
… a cherished recipe; chunks of tomato,
cream, fresh herbs, and other
delicious
things
Griddled Smoked Mozzarella Sandwich … 14.25
… with sliced avocado and fresh tomato
on 8-
grain bread with a side of mango,
pineapple
and jicama slaw
Classic Open Faced Tuna Salad Sandwich … 14.00
… with chopped tomatoes marinated
in aged
balsamic, extra virgin olive
oil, and basil,
served with garlic rubbed sliced
grilled
sourdough
Fresh Roasted Turkey Club Sandwich … 14.25
… real roast turkey, with warm smoky
bacon,
sliced tomatoes, romaine and
smoked
mozzarella on 8-grain toast
with maple
mustard mayonnaise and
served with our house cut french
fries
One Great Simple Burger … 13.95
… fresh ground beef, charbroiled and
served
with arugula and sliced tomato
and our
house cut french fries
… with cheddar or gruyere cheese…add
1.00
|

Poached Salmon “Cobb” Salad … 14.95
… chilled, fresh poached salmon, sweet
corn,
cucumbers, wheatberries, tomato
relish
and romaine lettuce with basil
buttermilk
dressing. Roasted chicken may
be
substituted for salmon.
Grilled Fresh Dolphin or Sautéed Lump Crabmeat and Key West Pink Shrimp Cake … 14.95
… served with a salad of baby lettuce,
snap peas, cherry tomatoes
and
sliced new potatoes, dressed
with a citrus
soy vinaigrette
|
|
Sara’s
Velvety Cream of Tomato Soup … 8.25
… a
cherished recipe; chunks of tomato,
cream, fresh herbs,
and other delicious
things
Our
Traditional Caesar Salad … 7.75
(may be
ordered as a main course … 13.00)
… cold
and crunchy hearts of romaine
lightly dressed
with a simple combination
of fresh egg, anchovy,
lemon, garlic and
parmesan, served with crispy
sourdough
croutons and shaved aged parmesan
Just
a Little Salad … 7.25
… a
salad of baby lettuces, snap
peas, diced
cucumber with a citrus soy
vinaigrette
Calamari … 8.25
… light
and crispy, with a dipping sauce of
chile,
lime and coconut
Bruschetta … 8.75
… grilled
sourdough, lightly rubbed with
garlic
and olive oil, and crowned with
balsamic marinated tomatoes
with basil,
black olives and gorgonzola cheese
Chilled Key West Pink Shrimp … 10.00
… served over grilled fresh pineapple
and sliced avocado with aged balsamic
vinegar reduction
Roasted Fresh Red Beets & Gorgonzola … 9.00
… arugula, dried cranberries and dressed
with sherry vinaigrette
|
Simply Roasted
Chicken … 18.50 (except on Sundays)
… seasoned and roasted ½ chicken served with mashed
potatoes and
sautéed green beans with mushrooms
|
Cool Plates for Hot Nights...17.00
Key West "Pinks" Shrimp Salad
Poached Wild Salmon Cobb Salad
|
Lump Crabmeat and Key West Pink Shrimp Cakes …22.50
… cornmeal crusted and sautéed, and served over baby
greens tossed
with our jicama, mango and pineapple slaw
Grilled Fresh Filet of Mahi Mahi …22.00
… with coconut rice and a cool tomatillo salsa
Fresh Filet of Salmon …21.00
… sautéed with fresh herbs,
and crispy goat cheese polenta
Fresh Sea Scallops …25.00 (when available)
… pan seared, and served with crispy fresh goat cheese
corn polenta with jalapeno
Straight From The Grill …24.75
…parsley and garlic marinated Skirt
steak, grilled and served
with our French Fries, and sautéed
mushrooms
Individual Old-Fashioned Baked Meatloaf …19.25
… with mashed potatoes and green beans
Green Chile Pepper Macaroni & 3-Cheeses …14.95
… a wonderful combination of aged cheddar, mozzarella and
parmesan cheeses with roasted poblano peppers
Old Fashioned Fried Chicken …18.75 (Sunday only)
… 3 pieces, served with mashed potatoes and crunchy savoy cabbage cole slaw
Whole Local Fresh Yellowtail Snapper …26.00
… virtually boneless, flash fried and served with a crisp
arugula and fennel salad (when available)

|

Breakfast … Wednesday,
Thursday, Friday … 8:00
- 11 a.m.
Lunch … Wednesday,
Thursday, Friday … 11:00
- 3 p.m.
Brunch … Saturday & Sunday … 8:00
a.m. - 3:00 p.m.
Dinner … Wednesday - Sunday … 6 - 9:30
p.m. (last seating)
Christmas till Easter open Mondays for breakfast & lunch too!
Call for special holiday hours.
Reservations accepted for parties
of six or more.
Click on one of the Reviews
below to hear what they're saying about Sarabeth's:
Key West
The Newspaper
Key Wester
Magazine
Shop Sarabeth's Online
530 Simonton Street @ Southard
Key West, FL 33040
305.293.8181
|
|
 |